Sinn Féin - On Your Side

Oireachtas Lisbon Committee Report ignores Irish electorate

25 November, 2008 - by Pearse Doherty TD


Sinn Fein Senator Pearse Doherty has this afternoon criticised the Oireachtas sub committee on Lisbon draft report being amended this afternoon describing its contents as being out of step with the views of voters and for not reflecting the very real concerns of the people in key issues of democracy, workers rights, public services, defence and neutrality. Sinn Féin intends to publish its own minority report on Thursday to counterbalance the committees report due for release on the same day.

Senator Doherty said:

“Sinn Féin took its place on the Oireachtas Sub Committee on Lisbon to play a constructive role in addressing the issues raised by the Irish people during the Lisbon Treaty campaign. We were concerned from the outset that the purpose of the committee was to prepare the ground for a re-running of the Lisbon Treaty and not in fact to tackle the issues raised by the people throughout the referendum campaign or indeed engage with them on the future of the EU and Ireland’s role within it. The draft report presented today confirms our concerns were well placed.

“The committees work programme and structure has been prescriptive. It has refused to bring the committee out to wider civic society choosing instead to bring into the Oireachtas the same voices that participated in the referendum debate.

“Not only has this approach not addressed the peoples concerns it also does the EU a great disservice. The committee process was an opportunity to meaningfully engage with ordinary people on what direction they believe Europe needs to take. It was an opportunity to listen to their concerns on the Treaty’s impact on workers rights, public services, tax sovereignty, decision making procedures and militarisation. It was an opportunity for politicians to interact with the electorate on Lisbon Treaty.

“Instead we have sat through weeks of the same politicians, lobby groups, academics and EU officials who have already loudly participated in the referendum debate, the majority of whom publicly supported a yes vote.

“During the referendum it was clear that the majority of political parties were out of step with the views of the electorate and did not understand the issues being raised. It is still clear six months on that the same political parties are still out of step and are now simply refusing to accept or uphold the views raised by their own electorates.

“The report we have been presented with here today reflects this political gulf between the main political parties and voters on the Lisbon Treaty. Sinn Féin has made wide ranging amendments to the report and as a result key sections need to be re-written entirely particularly on the issues of democracy, workers rights, public services, defence and neutrality.

“It is unlikely that the committee members will be prepared to accept any of Sinn Féin’s amendments which will leave us with no option but to withhold our support for the Committees final report. We will be publishing a minority report on Thursday to counterbalance the committees report due for release on the same day.” ENDS

Connect with Sinn Féin